Edit the justifications of the debate: God is a contradictory concept

To edit this page, please answer the question that appears below (more info):

Wikidebates is an encyclopedia of... ?

Warning: You are not logged in. Your IP address will be publicly visible if you make any edits. If you log in or create an account, your edits will be attributed to your username, along with other benefits.

The justifications below are arguments that aim to prove the validity of an argument in the debate. A justification can always be rephrased with a sentence beginning with “Yes, because…” or “Indeed…”

These justifications can be:

the logical premises of the argument;
thematic variations of the argument (examples of justifications for “Western Europe is in decline”: “Western Europe is in demographic decline”, “Western Europe is in economic decline” and “Western Europe is in cultural decline”);
studies, testimonies and other factual elements that corroborate the argument;
the general principles underlying this argument (examples of justifications of “The universe has a first cause”: “Matter cannot exist by itself”, “An infinite past is impossible ” and “There cannot be an infinity of causes”).

Each justification is the subject of a specific page which sets out its reasoning, its own justifications and its possible objections. Making the justifications explicit in this way makes it possible to deal separately with each of the elements of the reasoning on which the argument is based.

.

To rename an argument: edit the “Title to be displayed” field of the argument you wish to rename.

Note: to correct the name of the argument page, go to the detailed page of this argument and click on the “rename” button at the top of the page.

To delete an argument: click on the cross in the black circle that appears at the top right of the argument.

To change the order of the arguments: click on the dotted bar to the left of the argument you want to move, keep the click pressed, place your cursor at the desired location and release the click.

To add an existing argument: if you want to add an argument whose page already exists on Wikidebates, click on the “Add an existing argument” button and select your argument by entering the first letters of its title in the “Page name” field. Then write in the “Title to be displayed” field the title that will appear in the debate.

Briefly describe the changes you made in the “Edit summary” field at the bottom of this page, and click the “Save” button.

Warning banners

Depending on the box you check here, you will add a warning message pointing out the shortcomings of the “Justifications” section below:

Justifications to reorganize: justifications are redundant, need to be unraveled, or the structure can be clarified.

Justifications to reorganize

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Argument page name It is the content of this page that will be loaded into the debate. On Wikidebates, each argument has a page that is dedicated to him. You can thus use the same argument several times and in different debates. This field is required.
Title to be displayed A shorter or more punchy title can be displayed instead of the page name above. Take the opportunity to lighten it and make reading more fluid. Example: Argument page name: God exists because the universe has a first cause Title to be displayed: The universe has a first cause This field is required.
Warning(s) If the title to be displayed poses a problem, report it by checking the corresponding box(es): Unclear displayed title: the title is confusing, jargon, overly allusive or telegraphic; Too long displayed title: the title contains several sentences or is globally too developed; Unfavorable displayed title: the title presents the argument in a lacunary or caricatured way.	Unclear displayed title Too long displayed title Unfavorable displayed title

Add an existing argument

Edit summary:

Click on the operation(s) you performed so contributors can quickly understand your changes:

Renamed argument
Deletion
Reorganization
Added existing argument

This summary will appear in the page's history, as well as in the recent changes feed.

This is a minor edit

Watch this page

Cancel

Search

Edit the justifications of the debate: God is a contradictory concept

Navigation menu