Police violence and racial profiling

From Wikidebates
Wikidebates, the encyclopedia of “pro” and “con” arguments
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Parent debateThis argument is used in the debate Should the police be abolished?.
Argument forThis argument is a “pro” argument in the debate Should the police be abolished?.
Keywords: none[ edit ].

SummarySummary
[ edit ]

QuotationsQuotes
[ edit ]

“49 %. This is the proportion of black and mixed-race people of black descent who have already been controlled at least once by the police. A figure twice as high as for the French population as a whole (23%).

Elisa Covo, “Discrimination barometer reveals the extent of anti-black racism in France”, Madmoizelle.com, February 16, 2023.

Template:CitationTemplate:Citation

ReferencesReferences
[ edit ]

Arguments forJustifications
[ edit ]

  • Argument forDisproportionate use of force
  • Argument forRacist attacks
  • Argument forActive complicity of the IGPN
  • Argument forPersons convicted on the basis of false police statements
  • Argument forPolice assume they are carrying out ideologically-oriented persecution
  • Argument forUnder the same act and circumstances, a criminal conviction will be more severe if the person is racialized.
  • Argument forPolice racism is denounced by people who are themselves (ex-)police officers
  • Argument forPolice harassment in the suburbs
  • Argument forExchanging racist remarks off the record
  • Argument forFacial control

Arguments againstObjections
[ edit ]

  • Argument againstThe police are themselves of mixed race, so they cannot be structurally racist.
  • Argument againstThere are racist acts committed by police officers, but we cannot incriminate the police in general for these ultra-minority abuses.
  • Argument againstMany delinquents are young men from working-class neighborhoods; it's an effect of the composition of these neighborhoods that the police control racialized people.
  • Argument againstCases of police violence are controversial, the public sees them as "racist" and the courts often exonerate the police in the end.
  • Argument againstFake news" circulating about the number of victims of police violence
  • Argument againstFortunately, police violence is still rare compared to the pressure and attacks they face, particularly in working-class neighbourhoods.

Parent debateParent debate