Jump to content

Consciousness cannot be explained by matter

From Wikidebates
This argument is used in the debate : Does God exist?.
This argument is an objection to : There is no spirit outside matter.
Keywords: God .

Summary 

Quotes 

« we have independent reasons for believing that materialism is a false doctrine. Thus, the philosophical theory of mental activity convincingly demonstrates that materialism is incapable of explaining by reduction or emergence not only the existence of the higher operations of the mind (total self-reflection, apprehension of abstractions), but also the existence of mere "phenomenal" sensory consciousness (i.e. consciousness as subjective experience): we must necessarily assume the existence of non-derivative, intrinsically spiritual properties, susceptible of degrees of intensity. We thus have proof that spirit - if by spirit we mean "first-person existence", in other words, consciousness - is an indubitable, irreducible, ineradicable reality. »

Frédéric Guillaud, God exists, p.155-156, Éditions du Cerf, 2013

References 

Justifications 

Objections 

Parent debate