Jump to content

Collective hallucination has never been observed in thousands of people.

From Wikidebates
This argument is used in the debate : Does God exist?.
This argument is an objection to : It's a collective hallucination.
Keywords: none .

Summary 

Quotes 

« Hallucinations can be of various kinds (visual, auditory, tactile or psychic), but they always manifest a disturbance in a person's brain. They systematically occur in a context of personality imbalance or destructuring, and are generally accompanied by various behavioural disorders (agitation, fluctuating anxiety, inappropriate behaviour, etc.). This is why true "collective hallucinations" are a priori medically and logically impossible: they would presuppose that the same disturbances occur identically and simultaneously in different brains, in the absence of any objective external cause. »

Michel-Yves Bolloré, Olivier Bonnassies, God, science, evidence: the dawn of a revolution, p.483-484, Guy Trédaniel

References 

Justifications 

Objections 

Parent debate